Impact of using Artificial Intelligence on Human Cognition

Humans have been on earth since 3 million years ago which sounds quite a huge number but considering the history of the Earth itself, they haven’t been here for long. If we scale down Earth’s age to 24 hours, humans have been on Earth for only mere 5.7 seconds. Such information would likely trigger an existential crisis for anyone. As humans, or the homo sapiens to begin with, started to thrive and survive, they learned to improve themselves in certain tasks, or rather that they understood that not all tasks could be done only by hands. Humans learned to use different tools, to hunt, to protect themselves from wild animals and hence survived through all the highs and lows. These kinds of tools supported their physical tasks and a surprising fact is how all those tools still exist today to support humans in their physical tasks and make their workload easier. The stone flakes and hand axes used back then are now available in smaller sizes as a kitchen knife to cut vegetables or meat. It’s almost interesting how humans evolved and modernised to help themselves and make their physical workload easier. But as time passed, and many many modern technologies developed over the years, the human mind was successful to develop yet another tool to help their cognitive processes as well. It’s kinda thrilling to see how humans have become so powerful with such a technology, that technology being the internet. Yes, the internet has been on Earth as a part of human’s lives since around the last 30 years or so. It’s almost shocking to see how the existence of this one unseen entity of sorts could make human life so much easier. Whether it was clicking pictures of random things, watching tutorial videos to understand something, connecting to someone easily around the globe, and all sorts of those things all at once and through only a few electronic devices.

One of the major aspects that’s going to be involved in human evolution is going to be the internet. But as human brains have grown and evolved there has been yet again a major invention that’s going to be fundamentally reshaping how we think, learn, and interact with the world, which is, Artificial Intelligence (AI). Although the term has existed for a very long time, first coming into existence as an idea in Alan Turing’s paper “Computer Machinery and Intelligence”. Turing laid out what came to be known as the Turing Test or ‘The Imitation Game’ which was an adaptation of a victorian style game where interrogators were supposed to guess which is which. In Turing’s imitation game, a computer program was replaced with one of the human beings and the interrogator had to determine which was the computer and which was the human. If the interrogator was unable to differentiate, then the computer was considered to be ‘thinking’ or to possess Artificial Intelligence. Few of the different names used for ‘thinking machines’ included cybernetics and automata theory. Finally the term was officially coined 1956 by Professor John McCarthy at Dartmouth College where the idea of thinking machines was clarified and the name “artificial intelligence” was chosen for the project.

Now almost 60 years later, the internet has developed rapidly and so has there been rapid developments in the field of Artificial Intelligence. The Internet aided in information processing at a fast speed to help human beings in their day to day tasks, whether on a personal or a professional scale while AI has transformed the world by giving it the ability to make decisions, think creatively and process vast information. It’s almost unfathomable to think how human beings are now capable of doing some tasks in just a few seconds which would have taken them almost months or even years to complete a few 50 or 100 years back.

Cognitive Offloading in simple terms would mean to offload mental information to an external store to remember it. It’s almost like lifting off the weight off our memory to store it somewhere else our brain can focus on other tasks as well. We as humans are bound to indulge in cognitive offloading even without AI. Whether it’s making a normal grocery list, or maybe a to-do list, or writing down all our passwords in a secret notebook so we don’t forget about it. This way we’re able to lift off that weight from our memory. But now, with the development of advanced AI tools, we can not only store our important data in an external store but also retrieve and recall long-forgotten information with ease. Has this cognitive offloading process through AI tools enhanced our cognitive abilities or worsened them for the future? Some researchers have suggested that AI might shape human evolution, either by making us dependent on it, or increasing our cognitive capabilities. While offloading can help us handle more information than our brains can on our own, and might help boost our performance by helping us not retrieve a lot of information at once, it can most definitely mess with our ability to remember things later, hence ruining human being’s memory capacity.

Critical thinking is one of the most important abilities students need to have in today’s times. It’s the multifaceted ability to think clearly, logically, observing all sides of an argument before finally coming to a conclusive statement about any given topic. As a college student, questioning, analysing and evaluating information before making any kind of decision is very important. While there are researchers trying to prove how AI can support students in critical thinking, all by offering them personalised learning experiences, access to diverse viewpoints and facilitating analytical discussions (He Jun et al, 2024). There are many other researchers as well who have pointed out that pervasive availability of AI tools offers quick solutions and readymade information, and can discourage users from engaging in the cognitive processes essential for critical thinking. There have also been concerns that the over utilisation of such AI tools by students for even the smallest of decisions can affect their critical thinking skills and they’ll become more accustomed to the AI provided answers to everything (Gerlich, M., 2025). The overall development of AI detector tools in educational and professional institutions has been done only because of how there has been a rapid increase in the over reliance of human beings on AI tools even for the simplest of tasks assigned to them. In today’s times, there is a huge AI dilemma. While it holds immense power to increase our cognitive efficiency, its overuse can also hamper our very essential critical thinking skills. As it can be understood, there is a need to find a balance, so that humans don’t lose the ability to think for themselves.

Decision making, whether it’s a decision as small as to decide whether to eat eggs or sandwich for breakfast in morning, or something as big as a career related decision, anyone can agree at how important it is to make sure that all the proper points and information is taken into account before making that decision. Humans tend to have cognitive avoidance towards making big decisions, because such choices can often involve uncertainty about things, and may even cause them emotional distress. Endler and Parker (1994) gave the three types of coping strategies, one of the most important of these strategies is the Avoidance Oriented Strategy, as to how a human tends to avoid facing a particular situation in order to cope with it. It’s the sore truth of life, humans have always avoided making the bigger decisions. And hence, with the rise of the power of AI, humans have been able to make their big decisions, or perhaps get that similar sort of efficiency through AI. If we go through the objective points as to how AI has been able to help humans in making decisions, we will realise how efficiently, consistently and with great accuracy AI has been able to solve many of our problems. It’s as if we as humans require that kind of a guidance or perhaps a reassurance from a technology like AI since it is the closest thing to human intelligence ever created by humans themselves. AI techniques like predictive analytics fitted with the machine learning algorithms have been able to identify and analyse the patterns and even predict future outcomes (Provost & Fawcett, 2013) which can be helpful in various domains like finance marketing. But just as we humans may think that having an escape from taking our own decisions with the help of AI is great, we need to realise that it also has its own drawbacks, afterall, it’s still basically a machine without human emotions and moral judgement i.e. it lacks the intuition and the empathy required while making important decisions. AI may be able to provide decisions based on what we want, but at the end of the day it’s still a creation of human beings and not so perfect. Researches have shown that if the data provided to a particular AI tool is incomplete, inaccurate or biased, it is most likely to lead to faulty outcome (O’ Neil, 2016). Another problem that can arise with decision making through AI is the problem of algorithmic biasness. There can be bias present in the data or perhaps the algorithm on the basis of which the AI tool was built which can cause a faulty outcome overall. There has also been a rise in the privacy concerns regarding the development of AI tools, how much information should be shared for decision making, is the sensitive data of people used somewhere else, and is the personal data indeed protected by the company which developed the tool or not. From what it may seem, maybe AI is something that cannot be trusted by humans to make all kinds of their decisions. Humans are cognitively built to make their own decisions while also analysing situations and thinking critically. It is evident that while AI has had a global impact (by becoming a part of everyone’s lives), it has also influenced human cognition, making individuals increasingly reliant on AI for decision-making. It seems as though the trust in making the right decision has shifted from the human mind to machine learning algorithms.

It’s important to know that a child’s cognitive development starts from as early as the prenatal stage, even when they’re inside the womb. As Piaget has talked in his stages of cognitive development, skills like problem solving and abstract thinking become more apparent in the formal operational stage which begins at the age of 12. As Piaget has mentioned in his theory about the major key concept of adaptation, it can be noted that many AI tools can very well provide an interactive and adaptive environment for the development of a child’s cognitive skills. There have been developments of AI tools like Socratic AI which acts as a facilitative tool, not only for children but also for adults to learn concepts, understand them better and then move on to the complicated tasks as well. AI-based tutoring systems always analyze the response of the learner through algorithms then give feedback coupled with necessary next steps to solve such problems, encouraging more logical reasoning and critical thinking in learners (Göçmez & Okur, 2023).  AI has enhanced the problem solving ability more in children than adults according to a study done by Williams et al. (2024). It shows that cognitive improvement through AI tools might be affected by the age factor or perhaps the cognitive development stage.

Due to the rising issue of cognitive offloading, it’s easily witnessed in today’s societies that excessive use and over reliance on the technology of Artificial Intelligence has resulted in a major setback for human cognitive skills. People have become excessively reliant on even the easiest of tasks, ruining their own critical thinking and problem-solving skills. Integration of AI in our everyday lives sounds like an amazing idea until we realise how deeply it can make us over dependent on it. The cognitive decline has been one of the major research topics in today’s times and the major question which arises with it is whether AI will overtake human intelligence one day.

Logically speaking, humans have successfully programmed AI models to mimic human behavior and emotions, teaching them how to act and respond like real individuals. There are moments when we find ourselves wondering if our favorite AI chatbot could solve our problems and make decisions for us. There are actual AI models like Character AI, trained to act exactly like human beings, and which can be further trained by individuals themselves to act in certain ways.  However, at its core, AI still lacks human qualities and emotions; ethics, empathy, dignity, and the deep sense of belonging that defines human existence. If by chance, those childhood fears of AI taking over the world ever come true, the blame would go not on AI’s rapid advancement but on humanity’s overdependence on it. As we continue to evolve, this over reliance could lead to a rapid decline in our own cognitive skills, and eventually make us the reason for our own downfall.

What could be an actual situation to such a dire problem then? It’s one solution could be to use AI not as a problem solver, but rather as a facilitator or a support tool. It should be trained in a way that it inculcates human decision making rather than replace it completely. Another solution to it could be to use AI not as a decision maker, but rather as a collaborative partner. A kind of partner which helps you in doing something rather than doing it for you. Another personal yet controversial opinion of mine is that restricting AI’s level of creativity could, in turn, preserve human creativity and protect their natural evolution in some way as well.

In conclusion, we realise that AI is undoubtedly an extremely powerful tool which can either make humans reach greater levels of evolution or perhaps destroy humankind forever. The real challenge is not just improving AI but making sure we don’t lose our ability to think critically and solve problems on our own. After all, true intelligence isn’t just about getting the right answer, it’s about learning, growing, and figuring things out for ourselves.

References

Grinschgl, S., Papenmeier, F., & Meyerhoff, H. S. (2021). Consequences of cognitive offloading: Boosting performance but diminishing memory. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 74(7), 1260–1274.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/17470218211008060

Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. (n.d.). A look back: The birth of artificial intelligence (AI) research. https://st.llnl.gov/news/look-back/birth-artificial-intelligence-ai-research#:~:text=In%201956%2C%20two%20years%20after,artificial%20intelligence%E2%80%9D%20for%20the%20project.

Gerlich, M. (2025). AI tools in society: Impacts on cognitive offloading and the future of critical thinking.

 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5082524&

He, J., Yao, W., Ali, N., & Khan, A. B. (2024). The model of improving college students’ critical thinking ability based on artificial intelligence. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. 478–492. https://hrmars.com/index.php/IJARBSS/article/view/21686/The-Model-of-Improving-College-Students-Critical-Thinking-Ability-based-on-Artificial-Intelligence

Balbaa, M. E., & Abdurashidova, M. S. (2024). The impact of artificial intelligence in decision making: A comprehensive review. EPRA International Journal of Economics, Business and Management Studies

https://eprajournals.com/IJHS/article/12294?

Abrar, F., Mehmood, S., ul Emman, S. K., & Kandhro, A. N. (2025). Cognitive development and AI: A longitudinal study of children and adults navigating problem-solving with AI tools. The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/389003598

Leave a Comment